Socrates MacSporran

Socrates MacSporran
No I am not Chick Young, but I can remember when Scottish football was good

Sunday, 18 October 2026

Let's All Laugh At Celtic - And The Other Lot

 

THERE I WAS, settled down in front of the TV on Thursday night, ready for the latest edition of Let's All Laugh At Celtic: confident Benfica would trounce what one friend (of a Rangers persuasion) had dubbed: The Lisbon Puty Cats – successors to the Lisbon Lions.

Tweety Pie might always get the better of Silvester, but The Eagles certainly, on the scoreboard, ripped Celtic apart 4-1 on the night. However, in truth, if both teams had been capable of being more clinical in the opposition penalty area, the game might well have finished something like 8-5 to Benfica; still a defeat but one which could be viewed as glorious rather than a hiding.

So, to an extent, Celtic were unlucky in Lisbon, too often hitting the frame of the goal or a Benfica defender's body, but, for all that element of fortune, the fact remains – there are several highly-paid members of this current Celtic squad who are simply not Celtic class and, for all his undoubted and proven ability as a coach and a man manager, Martin O'Neill cannot make silk purses out of several sows ears.

Thursday night's outcome will do nothing to calm the rough seas breaking around Celtic Park. When I was a boy, in the years BS, before Jock Stein returned to put an end to decades of Rangers' dominance, although the club won very little, they pulled-in huge crowds and for all the disappointments, The Celtic Family stuck it out and stood together.

I worked for a tyre company, in a depot just off Duke Street; my boss was a Gorbals boy, a former Junior internationalist, he would have given an arm for even one game for Celtic, but, the call never came. He wasn't a fan of The Four Families who ran the club at the time – but, he recognised, they, like him were Celtic to the core.

He travelled to Lisbon on that great night in 1967, he even went on that heart-breaking trip to South America the following season and he would regularly join the fans who went into Barrowfield to watch the team training every day. Indeed, I remember one rainy morning, we gave Tommy Gemmell, Bobby Lennox and Bertie Auld a lift along London Road to Barrowfield – Stein had insisted they run along to the training ground as a warm-up.

That particular boss is no longer with us, but I wonder what he would make of the current state of affairs at the club, with an embattled board fighting with the most-committed fans; a resurgant Rangers at the gate and regular defeats in Europe.

The Celtic Family at large still believes in the club; however, the feeling appears to be growing among them that the current Patriach Dublin-based Dermott Desmond is only in it for the cash and the glory. The board and the executives in-charge of the daily business side of the club – well, as far as a seemingly growing number of the family members are concerned, these guys, such as Chairman Brian Wilson, are simply not up to the job.

The fans' crave European success – they have been raised on tales of Lisbon, of regular runs to the latter stages of the major European competitions; forgetting the reality – Celtic (indeed Scottish clubs) have not troubled the scorer much in Europe this century.

The fans' solution – the board must spend, spend, spend. In saying this, they apparently forgot: Viv Nicholson, the Yorkshire woman who brought that phrase into common usage, ended up penniless and suffering from dementia.

The unspoken fact is, Scottish Football is so poorly thought-of across the world, and Glasgow is often seen as a bit of a backwater, that even Celtic and Rangers, for all their history, now have to pay larger wages than the player might be worth, to persuade even middling non-Scottish talent to join them.

They have, as I see it, two options:

  1. Spend more money on proven talent, with no guarantee of European success

  2. Go back to Celtic principles and rear their own home-grown talent from the ranks of the children of the Celtic family.

The problems with that second option are: to succeed, it would need a coach of Stein's ability, a board prepared to give him the time for it to work, and even then, there is always the chance that the best young talent would be enticed away by the greater riches available in England or Europe.

Even with the number of non-Celtic class players in the current squad, it is impossible to see the club finishing the domestic season outwith the top three in the league, and with possibly one trophy. Still, the current squad is not fit for purpose in Europe.

It's a bitter pill for the Celtic Family to swallow, but, until a North American style European “Super” League, run on a franchise basis and with American-style management, or England's Premiership becomes a proper UK league, then Celtic (and Rangers) will continue to be big fish in a very shallow pool and minnows in Europe.




SCOTTISH FOOTBALL-WRITING statutes demand, while a journalist may devote the bulk of a piece to one cheek of the game's erse, the other cheek has to get a mention, in the interests of balance.

Thus, if Thursday night in Lisbon was bad, what can we say about Saturday night in Dundee. Cards on the table here, I have always had a lot of time for Steven Pressley and have long thought of him as a better coach than he is given credit for. Perhaps it's his own downbeat personality that has told against him, but, right now, I think he is doing a good job at Dens Park.

This Rangers squad is still a work in progress and as such, will always be vulnerable to a committed, well-organised domestic challenge, which is what they got on Saturday night.

When the visitors led, I was still certain Dundee could haul them back, but, I certainly never thought the equaliser might come from just about the worst individual mistake I have seen from a Rangers' Captain.

If one of the Diddy Teams can put a consistent run of form together, this season, we might just see the Old Firm dam breached – both sides are now highly-vulnerable.




FINALLY – I was speaking to one of my fellow coffin-dodgers, who has this season, after some seasons on the bowling green and on other sporting pursuits, re-invested in an Ayr United season ticket.

I asked him about that hugely-controversial penalty awarded to Partick Thistle on Friday night; have a look, there are plenty of examples on social media. That was, without doubt, the worst decision I have ever seen n a penalty box. The Thistle player should have been done for diving rather than winning a penalty.

My mate felt it was terrible, before adding: “the one Dunfermline got the previous game was just as bad – the two worst decisions I've ever seen, against us, in successive weeks.”

Where was Rabbie Burns when required, to pen a critical piece in support of The Honest Men?



Wednesday, 7 October 2026

The Shortest Of Honeymoons

'TIS IN SOME WAYS a great pity the late Frankie Howerd wasnae Scottish – the sight of dear old Francis coming on TV and declaring: “Woe, woe and thrice woe” rather sums-up the mood of the Tartan Army this morning, following our capitulation to the Swiss, then the way we collapsed like a leaking bouncy castle against the Slovenians at Hampden.

When, in the eighth minute of the game, the referee had his conversation with VAR and decided Jack Hendry's night was over, I knew, we were fucked. Against a nation ranked 30 places above us (13th to our 43rd) we were going to struggle to get a draw, far-less avoid defeat. The thing is, you would not, given the difference in rankings – the Swiss after all did reach the last eight of the last World Cup and have, in recent seasons, become serial qualifiers for the bigger shows – have backed a full-strength Scotland team, even at Hampden, to have beaten them – or, in spite of generations of evidence to the contrary, does the average member of the Tartan Army's PBI still think: “We're Scotland – we're good at this fitba lark.”

I am loath to criticise the squad who were on duty over this International Break. Of course, they themselves will be their harshest critics; they will feel they let themselves and Scotland down. OK, they beat North Macedonia, as expected but, overall, they lost twice to a better team on the night – that's a simple fact we have to accept.

Already, some of the Fans With Lap Tops are having a go at new Head Coach Sebastian Pocognoli, since under his command that old Scottish problem, a failure to score goals has continued. I canot blame the Belgian for the fact, we don't have an international-class striker in our midst. Even a man down, in the first half at least, we created chances. Yes, we fell away badly after the turn-round, but, better Scotland squads than this one have had bad nights in the Hampden office.

I am starting to feel, perhaps Pocognoli will suffer in the same way as Berti Vogts did when he got the Scotland job. Vogts inherited a squad which included several key players at or past the end of their international shelf life, needing refreshment but with a system which did not allow for the necessary change.

For as long as our major (and minor) clubs find it easier and more-convenient to import third and fourth-rate non Scots to fill their first-team slots, leaving young Scottish players on the fringes, we will struggle at international level. Mind you, even if they were to go down the road of exposing young home-reared talent to first-team play, given the huge divergence between pay in the Scottish top flight and in the English Football League – far less their Premier League, these youngsters would be hoovered up and off down the high road to England before they had even completed their football apprenticeship.

Barney Ronay of The Guardian, in a typically over the top English report on that nation's 3-0 defeat of Czechia on Tuesday night, claimed that in taking his England tally to 90 goals in 125 games, an impressive average of 0.72 goals per game, 'Arry was scoring international goals at an average no player had ever achieved before.

Aye Right!! Hughie Gallacher's 24 goals in 20 internationals – 1.2 goals per game, leaves Kane half a goal per game behind the great Wembley Wizard. (Of course, to the likes of young Ronay – football didn't exist prior to the establishment of the English Premiership).

OK, football in the 1920s and 1930s, when the likes of Gallacher and Jimmy McGrory (1.04 gpg at club level: 0.86 gpg at international level) was a very-different game from today. But, on the other hand, you have to wonder how Kane might have coped with the pitches, balls and equipment of those days.

What Scotland would give for a striker as prolific as Kane these days, but, to be honest, we have struggled to put the ball in the net at international level since the end of World War II.

In terms of length of international career and goals per game scored, Hibs' legend Lawrie Reilly is probably our top scorer in the post WWII period. Lawrie scored 22 goals in 38 games (0.58 gpg).

Denis Law – our joint record international goal-scorer, managed 30 goals in 55 games (0.54 gpg) while Ally McCoist, arguably our best pure striker since Law, only managed 19 goals in 61 internationals (0.3 gpg), although his overall career scoring rate does exceed the 0.5 gpg which has long been considered the benchmark for an international-class striker.

Kris Boyd, arguably our best penalty box predator since McCoist, may have scored over 300 goals in his career, but, at an overall average of 0.44 gpg, while his international record (7 goals in 18 caps) gives him only a 0.39 gpg average.

A lack of scoring ability up front is not a problem I can see our new Head Coach answering any time soon, particularly if Scottish players continue to struggle for playing time in even a league as average as our top flight, far-less in England's top flight, or one of the elite continental leagues.

I see dark days ahead for the Tartan Army – their new Belgian CO has had a very short honeymoon.