CYNIC
that
I am, I reckon tickets for next month's Scottish Football Hall of
Fame induction dinner must be slow to sell. That's the only
explanation I can come up with for two “leaks” of information as
to who will be getting inducted this year.
Paul Gascoigne - inducted before some more-worthy Scots
I
have no complaints as regards Julie Fleeting getting in – this is a
thoroughly-deserved honour for a wonderful footballer, and a nice
lassie into the bargain. I have no qualms about Paul Gascoigne being
inducted as well – on footballing grounds.
Yes,
Gazza probably, more than most, merits that old put-down about
players wearing their IQ on their back, and yes, he has had his many
and varied off-field problems. However, I firmly believe, Gazza is
more to be pitied than scorned, I believe the only place he has ever
been truly happy is on the park, playing, and, certainly, if we were
gong to induct incomers such as Terry Butcher, Brian Laudrup and
Henrik Larssen, then why not Gazza?
Of
course, as soon as his inauguration was announced, the ranks of the
unco guid rose-up in condemnation. Ach! They've been holding Scotland
back since Rabbie Burns was a ploughman and part-time poet, what's
new?
I
do have a complaint, however, with some of the omissions. For
instance, since the HoF was inaugurated in 2004, I have been saying
Bob Gardner should be in there. Who he? I hear you ask. Well he is
number one in the, to date, 1183-name long list of men who have
played in a full international for Scotland. There is a direct line
from Gardner, goalkeeper in the world's first international football
match, and Hearts' John Souttar, the latest player to join the list.
Robert Gardner - Scotland's first captain
But,
there's more. When that inaugural international was arranged, back in
1872, Gardner was secretary of Queen's Park; he was the Scottish end
of the correspondence with the Football Association's Charles W
Allcock which got the game played, and, he captained the side. For
Scotland cap #1 to still not be in the HoF, 14 years after it was
started, is a disgrace.
Fourth-fifths
of Hibs' Famous Five, arguably the best club forward line in the
history of Scottish football: Gordon Smith, Bobby Johnstone, Lawrie
Reilly and Eddie Turnbull are in, the fifth member, Willie Ormond
isn't. Yet Ormond who was awarded the OBE for his services to
football, was a successful Scotland team manager, leading the side to
an unbeaten run and ninth place – our highest finish, at the 1974
World Cup.
Less-successful
Scotland bosses are in the HoF, what grievous sin has Ormond
committed.
Willie Ormond - why has he been overlooked?
I
have long been arguing: football is a team game, you win as a team,
you lose as one. “The Lisbon Lions,” the Celtic team which won
the European Cup in 1967 are all in there, both collectively as the
Lions, and individually. But, while the likes of Hughie Gallacher and
Alan Morton are in as individuals, the bulk of the Scotland team
known as the Wembley Wizards, the side which crushed England 5-1 back
in 1928, and against which every subsequent Scotland team is
measured, are not in.
Amazingly,
Alex Jackson, who scored a hat-trick that day is not in.
As
I said, the Lisbon Lions are in, and, while the likes of Leighton,
Miller, McLeish and Strachan from the Aberdeen team which won the
Cup-Winner's Cup in Gothenburg in 1983 are in there – would they
have won it without Rougvie, Cooper, Black, Weir and Hewitt and the
rest.
In
fact, that Aberdeen team went on to beat Hamburg, the European Cup
winners, to lift the European Super Cup, surely there should be a
full-team induction there. The same argument could and should be made
for the Rangers team which won the Cup-Winners Cup. If Barcelona
Bears such as Greig, Jardine and Johnstone are in – why not the
rest?
Wullie
Shankly is in – but not his brother Bob, who was also an excellent
manager, not least than when guiding Dundee to the European Cup
semi-final in 1963. Speaking of Dundee, Billy Steel and Alan Gilzean
are in, as is Bill Brown, but, what of Doug Cowie, or Alex Hamilton,
Ian Ure or Bobby Cox?
Junior
football is a major part of the game here. But, while we now have two
women inducted, with Julie Fleeting joining Rose Reilly, where is the
place for the legend that is Willie Knox – arguably Scotland's
“winningest” (to use an Americanism) manager when with Auchinleck
Talbot? What about some recognition for the great Cambuslang Rangers
team of the late 1960s and early 1970s?
The great Willie Knox - when will be be recognised?
It
is an uncomfortable fact of life, one largely ignored, but, the
“Golden Age” of Scottish football was not during the 20th
century, but in the 19th,
when we really were the best team in the world.
Aye,
inducting Charles Campbell, RS McColl, Bobby Walker and Andrew Watson
paid lip service to those great pre-WWI days, but, no recognition for
Dr John Smith, James Kelly of Renton and Celtic, or Tom Vallance of
Rangers' “Gallant Pioneers,” or Dr John Smith, or Alec Raisbeck
or Charlie Thomson – or any one of many great Queen's Park players.
Scant
recognition there is in the part the Vale of Leven played in
developing Scottish football, and when I remember, where is the name
of Sir George Graham, the man who ran Scottish football for three
decades and more as secretary of the SFA?
Jack Mowat supervises the pre-match pleasantries before Real Madrid v Eintracht in 1960
Tiny
Wharton is the sole referee inducted – where are the names of Jack
Mowat, or Peter Craigmyle? Archie McPherson is in, but not Arthur
Montford. Hughie McIlvanney, but not Dan Archer, or Alex Cameron.
I
appreciate, who gets in is a committee decision, and I also accept,
reluctantly, it's the induction committee's decision which counts.
But, I do feel, some of the guys doing the choosing, even if they are
Celtic supporters with lap tops, don't know their football history.
Because
I can think of a lot of players and managers who ought to be in there
before some who already are. However, that's football opinion for
you.
No comments:
Post a Comment