IT
IS a fact of life, which, unfortunately we men do not
discover until we marry, but, the female of the species is indeed
deadlier than the male. Women are more-devious, more-cruel, and far,
far-nastier than we poor males.
Which
is why I applaud Anne Budge for her decision this week to put
Director of Rugby Craig Levein in-charge of the Hearts' first team.
This might just be a wonderful example of those feminine qualities
outlined in my opening paragraph.
Ann Budge
Budge
and Levein may be, in some quarters, seen as a double act, or job lot
in the Hearts renaissance project. But, never forget – Ann Budge is
the one with the greater financial input – she is the boss.
She
backed Levein when he backed Ian Cathro. I still believe Project
Cathro could have worked, given time. That time was not given –
another example of the short-termism which has so-bedevilled Scottish
football. But, I also believe, Cathro would be a better number two,
or Head of Development than he will ever be as a Number One, or Head
Coach.
Project
Cathro had been dumped. Is there another Cathro out there? I don't
think so. Hearts must therefore move-on, which may, in the
short-term, reverting to the traditional Scottish management format
of the all-powerful Manager. However, Ms Budge seems set on the
Director of Football overseeing a Head Coach role. I believe, by the
way, she is right in this – it works elsewhere, why not in
Scotland?
But,
those potential Head Coaches Hearts have apparently spoken to –
Davies, Hartley, Pressley – having been brought-up the old way,
were not keen to work under a Director of Football (or was it just
Levein?), so, with time of the essence, Ms Budge has taken perhaps
the only, certainly the easiest option – and asked Levein to do the
job.
If
it works – great, Levein steadies the ship, Hearts get back to
challenging Aberdeen, Rangers and maybe Hibs and St Johnstone for the
right to finish second to Celtic. He then has time to further refine
his preferred management format, and school Jon Daly and Austin
McPhee in what he wants.
Craig Levein - Come-backs are always a risk
If
it doesn't work – Levein's head is on the block, he walks and a
manager who will be The Manager, can be appointed.
It
is only the fact I was married to a thrawn red-head for nigh-on
40-years, before she died and left me in the tender care of our four
daughters, which allows me to understand, far less work-out the
Machiavellian thought processes of the fairer sex.
THIS
being an international week, and Craig Levein being in
the news, I had a wee dig through the records. Levein, as Scotland
boss, was in-charge for 24 games, of which we won 10, drew 5 and lost
9 – giving him a 41.6% win ratio.
His
long-term replacement, Gordon Strachan, has now been in-charge for 35
games, of which we have won 15, drawn 8 and lost 12 – giving him a
42.85% win ratio.
Neither
Levein no Strachan has got us to the finals of either the European
Championships, or the World Cup. Levein is now seen as a “failure”
as Scotland boss, his escutcheon forever tarnished with the words
4-6-0.
WGS - the Fans With Lap-Tops love him, the ordinary fans are less sure
To
be fair, the foot soldiers of the Tartan Army do not, on the whole
rate WGS as a distinct improvement, but, crucially, he remains popular with the
Scottish football writers to an extent his predecessors, Levein and
George Burley never were.
But,
a one per cent improvement – is that something to shout from the
roof tops about - particularly when the outcome is the same, a failure to qualify for tournament finals.
Maybe
it's the system which is wrong and it would not matter a jot who was
in-charge, we would still be shite – we are Scottish after all.
Stupidity
is doing the same thing over and over again in the hope of things
turning-out differently.
You
have to try new systems and strategies, and, if at first they don't
succeed, then try something else that's new. Don't go back to the
system that failed before.