Socrates MacSporran

Socrates MacSporran
No I am not Chick Young, but I can remember when Scottish football was good

Sunday 30 December 2018

Ra Peepul Are Happy, But, Should They And We Be?

DOWN HERE, in God's Orange County of Ayrshire, where (allegedly) they still give you a picture of King Billy, on his white horse at the Boyne, to hang above the fireplace in your new cooncil hoose, life is good this morning.

 In East Ayrshire, you allegedly got one of these with the keys to your council house

The sun is shining, the bretheren, brown brogues polished to a mirror finish, are stepping-out briskly to worship at their local watering-hole. And if what the leiges term: “The Natural Order” has not quite been re-established, the "tattie-munchers" were humbled yesterday. They might still lead the SPFL table, but, only on goal difference and the upstanding hordes of Ra Peepul are smiling again. The dark days are behind them, and number 55 can be imagined, just over the horizon.

But, if I was them, or a member of the Celtic Family, I would be very worried as 2018 prepares to cede the stage to 2019. Because, for all their financial muscle and advantage, for all those questionable refereeing divisions, which we are told: “level out over time,” the Bigot Brothers are not running away from the field; season 2018-19 is not yet the usual one or two-horse race.

Kilmarnock, now in the hands of a proper football club manager/coach are but one point off the pace, Aberdeen, for all their inconsistencies, are tucked-in a further two points behind Killie, with the even more-wildly inconsistent Hearts not that far behind.

I have of late become a fan of the American web site fivethirty-eight. Now 538 takes a close statistical look at various sports and political events around the globe. One of their best features is their Global Soccer Club Rankings, a statistics-based system which ranks over 600 clubs in leagues from the SPFL to the Australian, from the Chinese to the Brazilian. It makes sobering reading for the Scottish game.

The data they use goes right back to the birth of league football in the 1880s, it is updated after every game, using their SPI (Soccer Power Index). Right now, for instance, they rank Liverpool as the number one club in the world, with an SPI of 92.9.

The Top Ten in the Global Club Rankings are:

  1. Liverpool – 92.9
  2. Bayern Munich – 92.3
  3. Manchester City – 91.8
  4. Barcelona – 91.6
  5. PSG – 89.9
  6. Juventus – 89.5
  7. Ajax – 88.0
  8. Real Madrid – 87.6
  9. Chelsea – 85.6
  10. Atletico Madrid – 85.3


Where you ask are our leading Scottish clubs? Ah! Not such happy reading. The rankings of the 12 SPFL Premiership clubs, of the 628 world clubs ranked are:

82. Celtic – 65.0
185. Rangers - 52.2
292. Aberdeen – 42.8
358. Kilmarnock – 38.8
401. Hibernian – 36.0
445. Livingston – 32.6
455. St Johnstone – 31.3
497. Hearts – 26.8
559. Motherwell – 21.6
600. St Mirren – 14.8
609. Dundee – 12.1
614. Hamilton Academical – 10.7.

These are 538's figures, if we look at the UEFA Club Rankings, which take into account European form, the story is not quite as-dismal. The UEFA Club Rankings and Co-Efficients take into account each club's performances in Europe over the past five seasons. At the moment their top ten reads:

      1. Real Madrid – 144.0
      2. Bayern Munich – 127.0
      3. Barcelona - 127.0
      4. Atletico Madrid – 125.0
      5. Juventus – 120.0
      6. PSG – 101.0
      7. Manchester City – 99.0
      8. Seville – 99.0
      9. FC Porto – 90.0
      10. Arsenal – 86.0

The UEFA rankings list no fewer than 450 clubs from the leagues in all 54 UEFA member associations, and the Scottish clubs' rankings are:

  44. Celtic – 31.0
185. Aberdeen – 5.5
205. Rangers – 5.25
221. Hibernian – 4.425
222. St Johnstone – 4.425
223. Hearts – 4.425
224. Inverness CT – 4.425
225. Motherwell – 4.425

These are the only Scottish clubs mentioned in the rankings, since they are the only ones to have tasted European competition in the past five seasons.

What can we learn from these figures? Not a lot to be honest, other than – regardless of whether you try to assess Scottish football in global or merely in European terms – we are shite. This may not be news to the average punter in the stands, but, this information has yet to breach the force field which exists around the sixth-floor corridor of power inside Hampden, where they still have not realised how poor we are, far less sought some new way of changing things to bring about improvement.

Once upon a time, when I was a young man – we actually fancied our chances against the top European clubs. We could go toe-to-toe with them and win. Today, while we are not yet at the stage of being a guaranteed win against such clubs, where once, Scotland expected against them, now: furrit tho' we cannae see, we guess and fear.

Back then, our determination to win could offset our failings in the technical department. The fact the average Scottish defender could not trap a falling bag of cement was not such a handicap. He could offset this by putting the fear of God into these mamby-pamby sand-dancing furriners.

Today, the continental player is every bit as tough as the home-bred Scots while, since the Souness Revolution, we have tended to import third-rate foreign players, rather than trusting our fate to second-rate Scots.

I live in hope, that, perhaps beginning in 2019, we will change tack, start once again favouring ball skills and technical prowess over the ability to run all day, trusting in home-grown youngsters, and, maybe, just maybe – in world football terms, the lion rampant will roar again.

And, if we can clean up our spectating act, from some of the rubbish we saw and heard yesterday at our two big city derby games – so-much the better.

Hae a Guid Ne'erday, when it comes. See you across in 2019.


Sunday 23 December 2018

It Looks As If The Real Manchester United Are Back For Christmas

CONFESSION TIME – I have, as 2018 has unfolded before us in all its awfulness, rather fallen out of love with fitba. Maybe it has been a hangover from Brexit; how can you get involved in football when, out in the real world, there is a genuine crisis going on.

 If yesterday is any guide, he will not be missed

Any way, just in time for Christmas, I saw possible salvation. This came when I watched the Manchester United v Cardiff City game last night. It fairly restored my faith in the beautiful game, to watch United take Cardiff apart. OK, it was only Cardiff, but, over those 90 minutes, the United squad rediscovered the swagger which had been squeezed out of their game by the Chosen One, over his three-year reign of terror.

I never saw Mourinho and United as a good fit. He has never encouraged or espoused the vibrant attacking football which is demanded of the repertory company inside the Theatre of Dreams. The Portuguese's mantra has always seemed to me to be: “We win 1-0,” whereas the United dictum has been: “OK, you score three, we will score four.”

That said, it cannot be easy being a United player. Even Paul Pogba, for all it cost United £89.3 million to bring him back from Juventus; will never be considered the best player to wear the number 6 United shirt – so long as there is someone alive who saw Duncan Edwards play.

 Paul Pogba

He's a good player, but, I still reckon this guy would be most people's first pick for the number 6 shirt in any Manchester United dream team.

 Duncan Edwards
 

Alexis Sanchez isn't a bad player, but, he just happens to have inherited the number 7 shirt once worn by George Best, (who also of course wore 11), Eric Cantona and Cristiano Ronaldo, to name but three. David De Gea is touted as possibly the best goalkeeper in the world – but, so too were Harry Gregg and Peter Schmeichel before him.

Some day, they might erect a statue of Marcus Rashford, Anthony Martial and Romelu Lukaku – but, will they ever match the legend of the original golden trio of Best, Charlton and Law?

They are standing on the shoulders of giants, yes, but, today's United players still have an awful lot of history – from the 1948 cup-winning team of Carey, Delaney and Co, via the Busby Babes, to the side with the “Holy Trinity” on-board, and on to the “Boys of '92” - bearing down on them.

And yes, it was: “only Cardiff,” but, to those of us who have a soft spot for watching an attacking Manchester United team going full pelt for goals – yesterday was a welcome ray of sunshine in what has been a mainly dark season.



HUGHIE McILVANNEY once reckoned Ali v Frasier, both in wheel-chairs, in an old people's home, would still be one hell of a fight. There would not be the athleticism of the Fight of the Century, or the Thrilla in Manila, but, there sheer competitiveness would still have made it interesting.

Hugh McIlvanney

So, bearing that in mind – the Scottish Premiership, quality-wise, might currently be shite, but, by God, this season is the most-interesting in a long time. I know the Lap Top Loyal and the Celtic-Minded sects within the Scottish Football Writers Association are duty-bound to try to con us into believing the quality of the Bigot Brothers' squads, but, the reality is, as is shown by the league table, they are no better than the “Diddy Teams” they are forced to play against.

I have long felt, if a provincial club manager in Scotland is ever able to persuade his players: “It doesn't matter how we get on against the Old Firm – but, if we can beat everyone else, the chances are, we will win the league;” then that manager could well succeed.

In accumulating seven straight league titles, Celtic's average accrual of available points has averaged 79.8% of those available. In 2016-17, they won 106 points out of an available 114 (38x3). That has been their best show of the seven, their worst was season 2012-13, when they took the title, with 79 points – 69.3% of those available.

The eight games against the Old Firm account for 21.05% of the available points; so, had any of the other ten clubs concentrated on beating every team, other than the Old Firm, and succeeded, then they would have won the league in three of the last seven seasons. The percentage of points available in games not involving the Old Firm, almost exactly equates to the average number of league-winning points accrued by Celtic during their current run of seven in a row.

It could also be argued that a team used to beating everyone else, would surely be capable of taking points, at least at home, against the Old Firm. Something there for managers to perhaps try to get their heads round.

Of course, so used are we to the big two winning, I sometimes think they are already 1-0 up when they kick-off against provincial opponents. A similar degree of expectation comes into play with the other sides. They might approach a game against one or other of the Old Firm with hope rather than expectation of victory, whereas, against any other of the provincial sides, it is expectation rather than hope which is uppermost in the players' minds.

I feel things are levelling-off in the Premiership this season. It is certainly the most-competitive it has been in years, with, almost at the half-way stage, four points separating first and fourth. I sense, Aberdeen and Kilmarnock can maintain the pressure on the OF up until and hopefully after the split. That would be marvellous.

We now have a three tier top flight, with the top four split by those four points. Tier two also contains four teams: Hearts, Hibs, Livingston and St Johnstone – split by just two points, while at the bottom Motherwell, Hamilton, St Mirren and Dundee are involved in a dog fight for survival.

The football might not be top drawer, but, the excitement and uncertainty surely is, and long may it continue like this.