WITH
ABSOLUTE confidence in RB Leipzig's ability to beat Celtic in Glasgow
last night, I opted for 'coonsil telly' and the BBC Alba coverage of
the crucial Scotland v Ireland Women's World Cup play-off.
Since
I was watching an excellent Simon Reeve documentary
on The Lake District on
BBC 2 – which I
commend to the House, I turned over to Alba just before the kick-off
and must admit, Scotland's early play did not fill me with much
confidence, as they allowed Ireland to seize the early initiative.
Then, when Caroline Weir had
that first half penalty saved, I recognised, this was the 2022 remake
of an old movie: Disaster For Scotland. I've
seen this one before, many times.
No
harm to the girls, who will be more-gutted than even the
most-experienced Tartan Army foot
soldier, but, as I saw it, on the night, they didn't turn-up. The
best Scotland performances are played out to the skirl of the pipes:
the sound of Scotland The Brave, Black Bear, Heiland
Laddie, The Barren Rocks Of Aden
going through our heads. Last night was more Flooers O' The
Forest paced.
I expect Scotland teams
to pass the ball quickly and accurately along the ground, at pace.
The way we slowly and painstakingly came out from the back, often
taking seven or eight passes just to get to the centre circle –
that's not how Scotland play at their best.
I
remember seeing a film of the 1970 Brazilians, arguably
the greatest team ever, in training. It was put to a Samba
beat. Sure, they brought the
ball out from the back, but, the rhythm and beat increased in
intensity after they crossed half-way. We never saw that crispness,
far-less Barcelona-style 'tiki-taka' from
Scotland last night.
There was a lot of
passing, but little passing and moving; nobody tried to pass through
the Irish, indeed, I felt the normally excellent Ms Weir – so-often
our play-maker, if she got the ball at all, got it maybe 30 yards too
far from the Irish goal.
In
any case, she was subjected to what was almost a basketball-style
'box-on-one' defensive
structure, put together by Vera Pauw, who
used her knowledge of the Scottish girls to good effect.
However, if four Irish
girls are boxed around Weir – why weren't the Scottish girls they
freed up, making good passes and better using the space they had?
The
long throw-in has been around almost as long as football. I can
remember Ian Hutchison setting-up
Dave Webb's FA Cup-winning goal for
Chelsea v Leeds United back
in 1970. That's 52
years ago. More recently Stoke City's Rory Delap used
to regularly cause chaos with his missiles from the touchlines. Last
night Ireland's Megan Campbell wrought
havoc in the Scotland box every time she went to the touchline to
take a throw-in.
OK,
fair play to Sophie Howard for
knowing the Laws and ducking under one such throw-in to allow the
ball to pass safely into the goal, but, as a former goalkeeper, I was
screaming at Lee Gibson,
that one, plus several other balls into the box, were crying out for
a goalkeeper to go and collect them. Sadly, it appears Mrs Gibson is
the latest in a long line of Scottish goalkeepers to have graduated
from the Count Dracula School of Goalkeeping – they
don't go near crosses.
Ach!
I've been living through Disasters for Scotland
all my life, this was just another one to add to a long list. I
console myself with the knowledge, some day that thing that's for us
– winning the World Cup for instance – will no go bye us. I just
hope I am still around to see it.
AT
LEAST, if you're a member of
The Celtic Family,
another embarrassing Champions League exit
was partially-soothed by events across the city at Hampden.
By the way, I almost
have some sympathy for whoever has possession of the biscuit tin
these days. Imagine escorting the UEFA delegate to his seat in
the Celtic Park Directors' Box, having assured him he is about
to witness the greatest display of home fan dedication in all of
football, then to look out and see that: “Against Hunger and the
crown” banner, displayed by the Green Brigade, and
wondering: “Fuck, how much is that one going to cost us?”
Back in the 1970s,
my great football-writing hero Ian 'Dan' Archer, described
Rangers as: “A permanent embarrassment and an occasional
disgrace.” This quote allowed Celtic to claim the moral high
ground, I think the Green Brigade are doing their very-best to take
their club down beside their great rivals in living down to Dan's
verdict.
BBC
Shortbread's Sports Department, like
its News Department, has
for many years provided a home from home for reporters with no
discernible talent. One of the best/worst of these was the
seldom-remembered Colin Calder,
a boring nyaff from Kilmarnock who swapped accountancy for giving
poor accounts of football matches.
Dear
Colin's Shortbread career ended shortly after, on the day David
Murray bought Rangers, he asked
'The Great Waldo,' Hearts' owner Wallace Mercer, if:
“Football clubs are now rich men's playthings?”
Waldo, to his great
credit, nearly skewered Calder to the Tynecastle wall and, shortly
thereafter, Calder's dulcet tones vanished from the BBC Shortbread
airwaves.
Maybe the Irish
billionaire, to whom Celtic is now something of a plaything should be
considering if he is getting a good return on his investment.
Celtic's collection of expensively-recruited non-Scots are clearly
good enough for our wee diddy league, but, totally ill-equipped to
compete at the top level in Europe.
Maybe
Celtic should use some of that clout they appear to think they have,
from being one of Europe's iconic football brands, to ensure, the
team which finishes fourth in their group in the Champions
League, drops into the Europa
Conference League, so they can
continue to make money out of European competition – even after
they have been found out.
THE
ABOVE noted, if Celtic have
problems, they are minor compared to those facing Gio van
Bronckhorst after Wednesday
night's hammering at the hands of Liverpool.
I
missed the worst of the Ibrox horror show, switching channels at
half-time, after seeing how easily Liverpool had equalised, and the
way too-many Rangers players were making it clear they didn't want
the ball, I knew it would all fall apart after half-time. So, I
switched to watching Jason Statham, (the
greatest-ever Scottish goalkeeper – when he played 'The
Monk' in Guy
Ritchie's Mean Machine)
flirting with Jo Lo in
'Parker.' At least, I
was entertained.
I
have been writing on here for years – the majority of this current
Rangers squad are simply: NRC – Not Rangers Class.
I accept, the days are gone when The Old Firm had the financial
muscle to compete with the top English clubs and thereby retain their
best talent. Nowadays, any Old Firm player who gets enough good
right-ups from the less-than-impartial Glasgow press corps will
quickly get a move to a mid-table English Premiership or Championship
club, immediately doubling his salary, but probably without advancing
his career very much.
The
paradox is – there are only a handful of English clubs which have
the caché
of being 'A Big
Club' in
the Old Firm sense: Arsenal,
Manchester City, Manchester United and
Liverpool certainly
meet that criteria, while you could make a case for Chelsea,
Tottenham and
maybe anywhere but on the pitch Newcastle
United.
So,
if the oft-mooted British
League ever
happens, the two Glasgow giants would probably be top half of the
table clubs, in the mix for the title and able to compete at the
sharp end in Europe.
However,
I honestly cannot see such a league ever happening, so perhaps, if
the NFL-style
pan-European competition ever
happens, we might see them in there – certainly in terms of
following, core support and history, they have a chance of being
considered.
Sir
Robert Kelly is
a controversial figure in the Celtic Family of today; in many of the
wider family's view, tainted by his leadership of the 'Four
Families' who
allegedly held-back the club for many years.
Certainly
times were different, but, Kelly was a veritable giant in football
administration circles of his days. Perhaps the kindest view is that,
by the time he was in-power at Celtic Park, between 1947
and his death in 1971,
the
'Corinthian
standards'
to which Kelly held were already out-dated.
Kelly
joined the Celtic board in 1932, becoming Chairman in 1947. While he
was a board member, Celtic were consistently second-best to the Bill
Struth-managed
Rangers. It is generally agreed, the Celtic board of the time didn't
manage the club well, and results back this up.
In
Kelly's first decade as Chairman,, yes there were highs – a
Scottish Cup win in 1951. plus victory in the one-of St
Mungo's Cup
competition; the Coronation
Cup
success in 1953; a League
and Cup double
in 1954,
however, the club's average league finish in that decade was 6th.
Then,
Kelly had the idea of the club growing their own stars and introduced
the Kelly Kids,
coached
by Jock Stein. This
had little short-to-medium term effect; the average league position
rose to fifth, but, while some future Celtic Greats, including the
bulk of the Lisbon
Lions were
'Kelly Kids' – the League Cup wins in 1957 and 1958 were scant
reward before Stein's return brought a Scottish Cup win in 1965, the
double in 1966 and the years of plenty which were to follow.
Sir
Robert Kelly's vision and belief took a long time to bear fruit. I
raise this in a section of this blog devoted to Rangers, merely to
make this point. Gio van Bronckhorst came through the Feyenoord
youth
development system, which, if not as celebrated and feted as that at
Ajax, has
also produced an awful lot of top players, including GVB himself.
I just wonder if GVB
could persuade the Rangers board to allow him the time to develop
their own players in the way he grew-up at his first club. I wonder
even more, would the Rangers' support stand for the possibility of a
period of fallow seasons, while the kids matured.
Past
experience tells me, Rangers would never countenance such a move –
we will never see a Rangers version of the Kelly Kids, or their
successors 'The
Quality Street Gang' come
out of Ibrox. They had the chance to do this when the club was
demoted to Division Two, but didn't take it.
The mistakes made back
then are now coming home to roost for the Blue half of Glasgow. They
did what they have always done, tried to spend their way out of
trouble and, again they have failed – the very proof of madness.
Losing
a big game 1-7 is not a new experience for Rangers. I just wonder,
however, how quickly they will learn from this one, and can they
recover? Because, the Ibrox theme song on Wednesday was that old
favourite: “The
Cry Was No Defenders.”
THEN,
as if to prove calamities come
in triplicate, we had Hearts' abysmal
display in Florence on
Thursday night.
Michaelangelo's
David has more cover than Craig
Gordon got, as once again: “The
Cry Was No Defenders.” At
least, in Robbie Neilson's defence,
he has such a lengthy injury list to cover, this one was always going
to be a perilous journey for the Gorgie club.
Under the
circumstances, a thumping for Hearts was always on the cards. But, I
just wonder, and this one applies to all three Scottish clubs – why
cannot our guys defend set pieces? Time and again we see our sides
embarrassed by the opposition's movement and awareness at such set
pieces.
I would suggest,
defending set pieces is one skill a side can easily practice in
training. Perhaps they do, but, if they cannot perform in real time,
in games, then maybe the players should not be being paid to play in
any case.
There
was this mate of mine, who sadly toddled off to the Great Pavilion in
the Sky earlier this year, who had played in the old First
Division in England – what is now the Premiership. He
was down at his old club for a celebratory reunion and speaking to
one of the club coaches, who asked him: “What are you
doing up there in Scotland? It used to be, you guys came down here
and could dominate games, you demanded the ball, then used it. The
Scots guys I see these days, they can run all day, but, they don't
want the ball and, when they get it, they tend to trip over it –
what has happened?”
That conversation was
reported to me at least a decade ago. I think, since then, things
have got worse. We really are in a bad way. And again I say, for as
long as they can shove their snouts in the trough, the blazers along
the sixth floor corridor at Hampden don't seem to give a monkey's or
the failing state of Scotland's game.
Not for the first time,
Private James Fraser, Walmington-on-Sea Home Guard, is proving
to the Northern Nostradamus.
WE
ARE ALL DOOMED!