Socrates MacSporran

Socrates MacSporran
No I am not Chick Young, but I can remember when Scottish football was good

Wednesday, 18 November 2026

Disaster For Scotland Again

SADLY FOR Lewis MacLeod, Richard Gordon and the other Tribunes to the Plebs who are paid to talk the non-travelling corps of the Tartan Army through recent Scotland games, none of them comes close to the descriptive power of the late, great, David Francey. Now David didn't quite have Bill McLaren's ability to keep coming up with uniquely-Scottish descriptive phrases, but, his oft-repeated catch phrase: “Oh dear! Oh dear! Oh dear! Disaster for Scotland” deserves an honoured place in the BBC sound archives.

Michael Stewart apart, none of today's talking heads can hold a candle to the old double act of David and Dan Archer; but, I suppose that's the dumbing-down of broadcasting in the 21st century. Furthermore, don't get me started on the dregs of the increasingly-shrinking written press. Yes, Britney Spiers is still in-harness, while Young Master Pattullo at The Hootsmon has matured well. Jonathan Norcroft has maintained that proud Caledonian tradition of taking the high road to England to show the self-appointed Master Race how the football-writing job is done. Those boys have become men, the lot coming up behind them – well, they're about as talentless as your average SPFL player.

If you're still with me, you will have established, Monday night's latest Disaster for Scotland has left me, quite frankly scunnered. If we carry-on as we are, my grandsons will be watching us lose regularly to Andorra, San Marino, Gibraltar and the other minnows of the game. We're shite, but that fact has not penetrated the feeble minds of the game's high heid yins, up there in that ivory tower along Hampden's sixth-floor corridor.

The zenith of Scottish international football was back in 1974, when we finished an unbeaten ninth in that year's World Cup in West Germany. We have been going downhill ever since.

The 13 players we used in that tournament: David Harvey; Sandy Jardine, Danny McGrain, Billy Bremner, Jim Holton, John Blackley, Kenny Dalglish, David Hay, Joe Jordan, Denis Law, Peter Lorimer, Tommy Hutchison, Martin Buchan and Willie Morgan were drawn from just seven clubs. Four came from Leeds United, three from Manchester United, two from Celtic with one each from Rangers, Hibernian, Manchester City and Coventry City. Every player was playing in the top league in either Scotland and England while their club games regularly included runs deep into the European competitions.

In St Gallen on Monday night, the team on duty was: Angus Gunn, Aaron Hickey, Andy Robertson, Scott McTominay, Ryan Porteous, Keiran Tierney, John McGinn, Billy Gilmour, Ollie McBurnie, Lewis Ferguson, Luke Graham, with Nathan Patterson, Ryan Christie, Ben Gannon-Doak and Kieron Bowie coming off the bench. This squad comprised two players each from Napoli and Bournemouth and one each from San Jose Earthquake, Brentford, Tottenham Hotspur, Los Angeles, Celtic, Aston Villa, Hull City, Bologna, Stoke City, Torino and Sassuolo.

If I was asked to select a starting XI from the two squads, mine would be comprised entirely of men from the 1974 squad, that's how much the quality of Scottish international footballer has fallen. That squad in West Germany had a core of Leeds players, at a time when that club was the benchmark team in the English top flight. OK, the present-day squad includes five players from Italy's Serie A, but only the Napoli pairing of McTominay and Gilmour and Bologna's Lewis Ferguson are with sides currently in the top half of the table.

Only Villa's John McGinn and the Bournemouth bench pair of Christie and Gannon-Doak are with teams in the top half of the English Premiership while the fact that Keiran Tierney is the only representative of our own top flight indicates how far that league has fallen in status. Also, 15 players drawn from 13 different clubs is hardly a recipe for a tight squad.

Eight of the 1974 squad have since then been inducted into The Scottish Football Hall of Fame. Mystic Meg I am not, but right now, Andy Robertson's 103 caps will guarantee him a place in the HoF, with McGinn and McTominay likely to also be inducted; as for the rest, Ah hae ma doots.

Both on social media and in the below the line comments on the various newspaper websites, there is already a groundswell of opinion forming, that the experiment with Sebastien Pocognoli isn't working and it is already time for change.

I again make the suggestion I have made a few times in the past – who do we give the job to? It's becoming even more of a poisoned chalice than the equivalent England job.

Giving the job to Pocognoli always, to me, seemed like a risky experiment. In fact, it could almost be said to be further proof of that old chestnut: “Repeating the same mistake in the hope of a different outcome is a sure sign of insanity.”

The last non-Scot to be handed the big job was Berti Vogts – an older, much-more experienced boss than Pocognoli. His reign began badly and went downhill rapidly. An awful lot of Scots are convinced, managing Scotland is a job for a Scotsman, foreigners just don't get the Scottish mentality.

But, which Scots might be eligible – should the SFA decide to drop the Belgian? For generations, a Scottish manager was a sure sign of success in England. Sure, we quote the success of The Holy Trinity – Matt Busby, Wullie Shankly and Alex Ferguson; but, there have been other Scots who tasted success in England's top flight: Tommy Docherty, George Graham, Kenny Dalglish and Graeme Souness, to name but a few.

Not that long ago, the English Premiership was awash with Scottish bosses, this season, David Moyes, at Everton, is the last Scot standing. Indeed, of the 20 managers in England's top flight this season only Moyes, two Englishmen and one Irishmen are from The British Isles – against five Spaniards and four Germans and various other European and South American post holders.

Then there is our own top flight. Only 5 of the 12 jobs are currently held by Scots – less than half. If the SFA lets Pocognoli go, and if they decide to return to having Scotland managed by a Scot – who gets the job? Who, other than Moyes, seems remotely qualified to take it on?

In any case, given the paucity of international-class Scottish players currently playing – who would want to take the job? I refer you to Private Frazer.



Wednesday, 4 November 2026

Bloody Hell - Football Is A Funny Old Game

SINCE IT involves Manchester United, I will begin this post with one of Sir Alex Ferguson's famous phrases: “Football – bloody Hell”. I might, however, equally obviously have gone with the Jimmy Greaves classic: “It's a funny old game Saint”.

These thoughts were encouraged from watching the Amazon Prime broadcast of Tuesday night's Manchester United v Roma, Champions League game, from Old Trafford. I watched the game in part because, after watching the worst Celtic team this century implode against Falkirk and marvelling at an equally poor but perhaps improving Rangers team huff and puff through their campaign so far, it was only fair that I watch the equally criticised United team.

Followers of these haverings will need no further telling, in my view the current squads at Ibrox and Parkhead are over-loaded with players who are, to conjur-up a collective description: Not Old Firm Class. The same problem is bedevilling Man U. There were guys playing on Tuesday night who would never have got through the door at Carrington, or before that The Cliff, in the days when United wasn't a punch line in a stand-up comedian's act.

MacSporran Meander warning: [in a former life, working for the Paisley Daily Express I was, one Monday, reflecting on yet another poor display by the then St Mirren team, with Love Street Legend Jackie Copland. Those who saw Jackie play will recall, he did not take prisoners and he was equally forthright as we talked.This particular morning, the object of most of his ire had been the performance of Buddies front man Junior Mendes. What had particularly annoyed Jackie was, Junior kept showing for the ball – holding an arm in the air and saying: “here I am”, while right beside an opposition defender. As Jackie observed: “a guy doing that doesn't want the ball – if he really wanted the ball he'd be looking for open space.”]

For Junior Mendes – some 25 years ago – read Bryan Mbeumo for United on Tuesday. Perhaps the biggest difference was, St Mirren got Junior for nothing, after he was released by Chelsea, United paid £65 million for Mbeumo. Now Junior was certainly no Frank McGarvey, Gunni Torfasson or even his contemporary Buddies Basher Lavety and Mark Yardley. But he was perhaps closer to them than Mbeumo is to the guys he will be judged against: The Holy Trinity, Eric Cantona or Wayne Rooney – to name but a few.

OK – Mbeumo did manage to hit both posts with one shot on Tuesday night, but, generally he ran around like a headless chicken and if that's what £65 million buys you these days, Fitba truly has gone to the dogs.

But he wasn't the only disappointment on view, indeed, the only two members of that starting United team I would keep would be Bruno Fernandez and Harry Maguire. They at least look as if they know what being a regular cast member of the Theatre of Dreams Repertory Company really involves.

I have just spent some time having a go at United, however, to quote another of the game's clichés: “It's a results-driven business” and United did win. That said, how a Serie A team such as Roma could let a two-goal lead slip is another question.

United might have got lucky with the order to re-take that penalty, but, coming back from 0-2 down to win just might be the change of fortune the embattled Michael Carrick requires.

Another interesting wee snippet from the broadcast was the opinion of Alan Shearer, that maybe the fact United recovered from a poor start to finish in a Champions League qualifying position was an indication that The Premiership might not be the wonderful league he and its other cheer leaders had built it up to be.

We all know and have known for years, the SPFL is a pish league – performances such as that by United and Roma has me wondering, are the much-vaunted Premiership and Serie A that much better?

Monday, 2 November 2026

Anthems For The Fitba Man

ACCORDING TO the brilliant Trevor Noah, Neil Diamond's great anthem Sweet Caroline represents the epitome of white joy. The South African comedian has clearly never been at Hampden after a Hibernian win – when Sunshine on Leith is being roared out by the entire King's Park End.

Hibs' fans belting out The Proclaimers' rabble rouser is widely considered the greatest Football Anthem, greater even than the Anfield Kop gien it laldy to You'll Never Walk Alone. Mind you, as I watched the television pictures on Sunday afternoon, I could not help thinking, a few of the non-Scottish Hibs' players definitely had that look which said: “What the fuck is going on here?”

[Diversion: I cannot remember who she was, but, I recall a female Scottish comedienne telling a story of how, when the song first came out back in the 1980s, she had attempted to sing it as her “turn” at the family's Hogmanay party. She got as far as “sorrow, sorrow” when her Grannie interrupted: “We'll have nae sad songs the nicht” was the order. From banned sad song to triumphant anthem – what a journey.]

Still on a musical bent, several Rangers-supporting friends of mine were in-touch on Sunday night, claiming that the soundtrack of 01 November, 2026 should be Daniel Boone's Slosh classic Beautiful Sunday. Mind you, this proposal owed more to events at The Falkirk Stadium than to the Hampden semi-final.

Thus, after a 200-word intro, we arrive at today's sermon.


Sunday's two televised games: Falkirk v Celtic in the League, broadcast on Sky and the League Cup semi-final between Hearts and Hibs, shown on Premier Sports supposedly showcased Scottish Football.

In all, including substitutes, 62 players strutted their stuff in the two games, only 22 of these – 35%, were Scottish. Also, of the 44 players who started the two games, only 14 – 32% were Scottish.

Falkirk used 16 players; they used the greatest number of Scottish ones - 7 with 4 starters and 3 coming off the bench.

Opponents Celtic also used 16 players; they had 3 Scottish starters and a further 2 used off the bench.

At Hampden, the two Edinburgh sides each used 15 players; in both cases, only 5 were Scottish. The Hearts' split was 4 Scottish starters plus 1 off the bench, while Hibs began with 3 Scottish starters and 2 off the bench.

What future hopes can we have for Scottish Football, if Scottish clubs will not field Scottish players?

Mind you, this over-reliance on bought-in, non-Scotland-qualified players just might lead us to the most-level Scottish playing field since David Holmes and Graeme Souness totally changed the face of the game back in 1986.

Souness took advantage of the English clubs being banned from Europe to import quality England internationalists to Rangers. Then, when David Murray bought the club, he broadened the recruitment area, by bringing-in some quality players from Europe.

OK, the Murray Method eventually faltered, leaving the club seriously embarrassed and, but for the fact, Scottish Football accepted Rangers were “too big to fail” and a buy-out prevented the club going the way of the likes of Third Lanark and into oblivion.

Celtic, having themselves only just avoided closure, courtesy of Fergus McCann's rescue act have been more-conservative than their rivals when it comes to player recruitment. Rangers were prepared to pay top dollar for top tier players – realising they had to to compete with clubs in the larger, better-funded and more-attractive European leagues and England's Premiership.

They can no longer do this, Celtic were never willing to, so now they are, instead of shopping in Football's equivalent of Waitrose or Marks & Spencer, never mind Harrods and Fortnum and Mason, looking in the game's equivalent of the central aisles in Aldi and Lidl for fresh talent.

There, they are rubbing shoulders with the lesser Scottish sides – the so-called Diddy Teams – who are slowly starting to realise, a lot of the Old Firm players we are facing are simply not Old Firm class. So, we no longer need to park the bus to try to limit damage when facing them, if we believe and have a go, the Bigot Brothers are vulnerable, to an extent they have never been in the past.

I can see a few more “shock results” such as Sunday's at Falkirk, and just maybe, if one of the Diddy Teams can sustain sufficient belief, a season which is something other than the usual two-horse race. Bring it on.

OK, I accept, even lower league English sides can now cherry-pick emerging young Scottish talent at will, which leaves some Scottish clubs with the attitude: “why should we bother breeding and nurturing home-grown talent, when agents are going to sell them to England or abroad at the earliest opportunity?”

It's difficult to argue against that level of thinking, however, as I have said before, and will keep saying, until we bring-in something like Charles Young Esq's “Eight Diddies Rule” - whereby there has to be at least eight Scottish-qualified players on the field in the two teams at any one time in a domestic Scottish game.

That way, we just might get back to promoting and seeing develop, quality home-grown talent, and Scottish teams doing better at both club and international level. If that's too-big and too-radical step, they could feed-in the minimum number of Scots gradually, starting with five, then building up.

Or, since the competition does not carry the prize of European football the following season after a club wins it – why not bring in the Eight Diddies Rule in the League Cup. Now, there's another way to further level the playing field.